This essay critically examines the failures of the youth justice system in Australia and its detrimental effects on vulnerable young people. It highlights the increasing number of young people in custody, the inadequate support for those with mental health issues or learning difficulties, and the disturbing incidents of mistreatment in detention centers. The essay delves into the systemic issues, including the overrepresentation of Indigenous youth, the use of harsh practices, and the violation of human rights. It argues for a shift away from punitive measures towards a focus on rehabilitation, timely interventions, and community involvement. The essay emphasizes the need to treat young people differently from adults, considering their developmental stage and the importance of promoting their well-being and social acceptance upon release, ultimately advocating for a more humane and effective approach to youth justice.