Climate Change and Policy Responses

This assignment delves into the multifaceted issue of climate change, examining its environmental and economic consequences. It analyzes different policy approaches to mitigate climate change, such as carbon taxes, renewable energy incentives, and international agreements like the Copenhagen Accord. The assignment also discusses the challenges associated with implementing effective climate policies and considers the role of demographic changes in shaping global emissions.

Running head: ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
Economics For Managers
Name of the Student
Name of the University
Author Note

1ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
Table of Contents
Introduction:....................................................................................................................................2
Answer 1:.........................................................................................................................................2
Answer 2:.........................................................................................................................................3
Answer 3:.......................................................................................................................................11
Answer 4:.......................................................................................................................................13
Answer 5:.......................................................................................................................................15
References......................................................................................................................................17

2ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
Introduction:
Over the last few decades one of the most bothering and disturbing issues in a global
level have been the drastic climatic changes and the phenomenon of global warming. Global
warming in simple words means an increase in the overall average temperature of the earth, at a
pace, which is faster than normal. This phenomenon, though not accepted by a few, is mostly
perceived to be occurring in the recent times and has been a cause of immense concern among
the global leaders and environmentalists across the globe, due to the short term and long term
threats it poses. The long term threats include huge changes in the global temperature, which in
turn may result in an overall change in the environment as well as demography, endangering the
lives of plants, animals and human beings (Fankhauser, 2013). Global warming, as suggested by
many, has been caused due to many reasons, one of the primary ones being the human activities
over the years. The most harming of these activities has been the huge and uncontrolled
emissions of greenhouse gases like carbon dioxide, methane and others, which aggravated to a
major extent since the last century. The concerned report gives a detailed account of this issue
and tries to analyze and seek answers to several important questions, based on Kenneth J.
Arrow’s article on Global Climate Change (Arrow, 2007).
Answer 1:
In the article, by Kenneth J. Arrow, the effects on the earth, positive and negative, due to
the occurrence of global warming and a rise in the overall level of temperature as a byproduct,
has been discussed and critically evaluated. The article discusses about the potential costs that

3ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
are expected to be borne by not only humankind but also other life forms existing on earth, due
to the aggravated pace of the global warming. There have been significant debates and
confusions regarding the extent of this cost and at what time this cost has to be borne by human
beings. The author however, tries to suggest the presence of global warming in reality with the
help of empirical evidences present. He also tries to discuss about the necessity to reduce the
emission of carbon dioxide by huge levels in order to prevent the future catastrophic situations
that are highly expected to arise if the emissions go on at the existing levels (Arrow, 2007).
The article attributes the phenomenon of global temperature increase, to a big extent, to
the trace gases, which are present in the earth’s atmosphere. These trace gases are primarily
composed of carbon dioxide, methane and water vapor and have the inherent property of
absorbing radiations at low frequency, thereby getting heated up. The proportion of CO2 has
been consistently increasing, even at a greater pace post Industrial Revolution, which along with
increasing the mean temperature worldwide, is also having significant impacts (mostly adverse)
on sea-levels, crops, vegetations, climate and life forms. The cost and benefit approach has been
used in this article to calculate the effects of taking restrictive measures on CO2 emissions in
near future (Trenberth et al., 2014).
Answer 2:
The author, in this article advocates for the immediate need for taking restrictive
measures on the uncontrolled emissions of the greenhouse gases, mostly carbon di0xide as s
being currently done by human beings all over the world, especially in the industrially developed
countries. These measures, according to the author are mandatorily required to avoid the huge

4ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
negative consequences from the global warming, which is being substantially caused by the
uncontrolled emission of these greenhouse gases. The implications, as suggested by Arrow, can
be short term as well as long term. The reasons, as put forward by the author, in support of his
suggestions, are elaborately discussed in the following section:
Scientists, environmentalists and global leaders across the world has overtime
unanimously agreed to the fact that one of the dominating factors causing this global warming
has been the natural as well as man-caused emissions of greenhouse gases, especially carbon
dioxide, from the beginning of existence of life forms on earth. These greenhouse gases, being
one of the comprising elements of the trace gases, have added bulks to the amount of trace gases
present in the atmosphere of the earth (Seinfeld & Pandis, 2016). The trace gases, having the
unique tendency of absorbing radiations when emitted at low frequencies, have caused the
heating up of the earth overtime. One of the major sources of the emission of carbon dioxide has
been the activities of the human beings, who, especially from the last few centuries, have been
contributing significantly to the share of emission of carbon dioxide in the earth’s atmosphere.
The levels have drastically risen from the time of initiation of the Industrial Revolution. Post
Industrial Revolution, these levels have significantly gone up with time (Lau, Lee & Mohamed,
2012).
The following graph shows the dynamics in the emission of carbon dioxide overtime:

5ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
Figure 1: Emission of Carbon Dioxide Globally
(Source: Scienceblogs.com, 2017)
The above figure supports the fact that the emissions have significantly from the
Industrial Revolution period, as can be seen that the emissions significantly rose from 1851, with
the pace getting increased post 1951. The emissions of carbon dioxide reached a threatening
level of 8000 million metric tons by the next century (Bondyrev, Davitashvili & Singh, 2015).
This massive increase in the CO2 levels has in its turn contributed to the abnormal increase in
the global temperature in the last few centuries, thereby creating a greenhouse like effect on the
environment of the earth (O'Neill et al., 2012). The direct relationship between the increase in the
levels of CO2 in the atmosphere and the increase in the global temperature can be seen from the
following figure:

6ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
Figure 2: Relation between levels of CO2 and Temperature overtime
(Source: Scienceblogs.com, 2017)
It is evident from the above figure that both the variables have a positive and direct
correlation thereby giving robust support to the theories of the author. The concern as showed by
Arrow, in his article, gets relevance from this data, thereby making the need to take appropriate
actions against this an absolute priority (Friedlingstein et al., 2013).
Substantial research has been carried out in this aspect and shocking results have been
received which shows that the levels of CO2 emissions drastically got hiked from 280 ppm (parts
per million) from the periods prior to the Industrial Revolution to 430 ppm since the initiation of
the revolution. Reports also predict the expected levels of these emissions to reach up to 550
ppm (2035), if the current activities and pace continue. This projected emission levels are scarily
twice of that of the levels existing before the industrial activities gained impetus. The levels, if
received, will be first of that extent in the last few of millions of years. These threatening

7ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
statistics pose a serious threat to the overall existence of humanity in the future, provided no
measures are taken to control and reduce it (Cook et al., 2014).
The article, along with substantial support from other research and scholarly works,
suggests that there are direct and substantial implications of these continuously increasing levels
of emission of carbon dioxide on the average levels of temperature in the world. The projected
rise in the levels of these emissions is expected to increase the average global temperature by a
minimum of 2oC in very near future. This emission pattern, if maintained, poses a threat of a five
degree increase in the global temperature by fifty percent probability, by the beginning of 2100,
if no corrective measures are under taken (Peters et al., 2013).
One of the many negative consequences that the emission of greenhouse gases and global
warming as a result, has on the global environment is the melting of the glaciers, thereby leading
to an overall rise in the sea levels as can be seen from the following graph:
Figure 3: Changes in the sea levels overtime
(Source: Climatecentral.org, 2017)

8ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
The alarming rise in the sea levels are observed especially between the fifteenth and the
twentieth century and is expected to rise faster and to a greater extent if the current trends of
global warming and melting of glaciers tend to continue. This, in its turn, poses a credible threat
of wiping out many of the populous landmasses, including huge land areas of low sea level
countries like Bangladesh. Cities like Manhattan and others also face threat of complete
extinction from the geographical map of the world forever. Two major glaciers of Greenland and
West America also faces the threats of melting, which if occurs, can create even bigger
catastrophe, causing significant loss to human life and properties (Hansen, 2016).
Another direct impact of global warming is the changes that the global climatic patterns
are expected to undergo with the increase in the average levels of temperature. The current pace
of global warming is expected to change the currently pleasant climatic conditions of Europe and
similar countries to the type of climate, which prevails in Greenland. The tropical storms are also
expected to intensify in magnitude and frequencies overtime, causing problems for humankind.
The decrease in the reserves of glaciers, with rapid melting of the huge ones, can lead to a
worldwide shortage of drinkable water supplies in near future (Bondyrev, Davitashvili & Singh,
2015).
All these consequences, collectively, poses threats to even the existence of life forms in
future on earth. These projections have led to creation of immense concern and tensions among
people all over the world and the projections are expected to be having enough potential for
causing catastrophe. Therefore, appropriate design and implementations of adaptive and
corrective measures, on a global level, has become a matter of immense priority and necessity, as
is discussed by the author, in this article (Pachauri et al., 2014).

9ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
Source of Failure in the Market:
Market failure, in terms of economics, is described as a phenomenon where the welfare
of the overall society is not maximized in a particular market structure. In this case, this issue has
relevance. The rate of emissions of carbon dioxide has significantly increased post the initiation
of the Industrial Revolution, as can be seen from the data and statistics provided by various
research and studies conducted worldwide. However, the positive gains of the industrial
revolution, as known by all, have been achieved by the few contemporary highly developed
countries, which were on the growing trajectory during the revolution period (Rezai, Foley &
Taylor, 2016).
The Industrial Revolution fuelled the growth and economic welfare and the overall
development of these countries significantly and embarked them on the path of sustainable
growth, as can be seen from their current performances. However, this growth in the economy of
these countries came at the cost of uncontrolled emission of carbon dioxide, due to the absence
of adequate awareness of the negative consequences and absence of appropriate restrictions
(Emanuel, 2012).
The burden of these activities is borne by the succeeding generations. The developed
countries grew and prospered at the cost of the underdevelopment of the developing countries,
which faced the restrictions and anti-growth policies to reduce emissions of greenhouse gases.
These caused a significant blow to their economic prosperity, keeping them poor and less
developed. Therefore, it can be see that the costs of economic growth of the developed countries
were not mostly borne by them but were in fact borne by the less developed ones as they are

10ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
mainly facing the tradeoff between growth and global well-being. This can be portrayed as a
source of market failure in this aspect in the global scenario (Rezai, Foley & Taylor, 2016).
Solutions to combat Global Warming:
To reduce the pace of global warming or to at least confine them to the existing level,
several measures can be adapted which can possibly help in reducing the levels of carbon
emissions. Some of these are as follows:
a) The replacement of the traditional high-carbon-emitting energy resources like coals and other
fossil fuels with those of natural gases can reduce the levels of carbon emission massively
(Emanuel, 2012).
b) One of the primary factors contributing to global warming is the huge deforestations that has
taken place over the years, mainly by men. Trees help in reducing CO2 levels and therefore
should be planted all over the world in huge quantities to combat global warming (Pachauri et
al., 2014).
c) Energy consumption reducing production techniques and innovations are an absolute necessity
and they should also be used worldwide to reduce the overall energy consumption levels. Both
developed and the recent developing countries should take this innovation and implementations
seriously (Seinfeld & Pandis, 2016).
d) The developed countries have enjoyed fruits of Industrial Revolution substantially. Therefore,
it becomes a responsibility on their part to take the proper initiatives to control and reduce carbon

11ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
emissions such that they can inspire others to follow their footsteps (Lau, Lee & Mohamed,
2012).
Answer 3:
The article uses the following equations to see the inter-temporal preferences of
consumption in general:
δ = ρ+gη
The term δ in this equation, shows the discount rate in consumption. This shows the rate
of discounting losses by an individual that is expected to occur in the future consumption if the
individual prefers to consume in the present period. This is an overall picture of the preference
pattern of an individual of current over future. Higher values of this term indicate that the
particular individual prefers to consume more in current period to future period (Sen, 2013).
The term ρ, in this equation is the rate of time preference. Higher values imply more
preference of an individual of current welfare over his or her welfare in the future. The term g
shows the expected growth rate of average consumption and the term η indicates the elasticity of
social weight as a result of a change in consumption levels. This is nothing but the economic
concept of marginal utility as there is an increase in the level of consumption (Goulder &
WILLIAMS III, 2012).

12ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
Figure 4: Social Cost of Carbon and Global Discount Rate (2010)
(Source: Source: Americanprogress.org, 2017)
Economic Intuition:
The equation implies that there are two factors contributing to the consumption discount
rate. The rate has a positive relation with the time preference variable as with higher time
preference, people value present consumption more than that of future consumption. Again, gη is
the change in the value of δ, due to an increase in the mean rates of consumption, keeping in
mind that increases in g decreases η (Sen, 2013).

13ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
The critique argues that uncertainty in the values of g leads to a fall in the value of the
consumption discount rate. This, however, may not be correct as with high uncertainty in the
growth rate of consumption, current consumption tends to be of more importance than that of
future consumptions. Therefore, the relation as suggested by the critique might not be true in a
generalized framework (Cropper et al., 2014).
In the given scenario, a country having a low value of the consumption discount rate
implies that the country in general prefers future consumption significantly and has a low current
preference rate. This implies that future consumption is also of importance to the residents of the
country. This economy, given the threat of aggravated global warming and its potential negative
effects, is expected to take pro-active measures to reduce emission of CO2 to safeguard their
future welfare. They can be expected to pave the path of sustainable development and can inspire
other countries to sacrifice their current welfare to some extent for future betterment (Cropper et
al., 2014).
Answer 4:
The article by Adam Morton, argues that the prices of power in Australia has gone up
drastically and has almost doubled after the axing of taxes on carbon. Their findings are backed
by many evidences, which suggest the same phenomenon. The cost of consumption of electricity
in the country, as a result, has also grown up due to this hike. Much of this is attributed to the
continually rising gas prices and also the investment uncertainty in the power sector. This is
arising due to the speculations and doubts among the investors regarding the future of the power

14ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
plants. Though these plants are the future replacements to the coal factories, their prospects and
credibility are matters of concern among the investors (Smh.com.au, 2017).
The article shows that though the country acknowledges the need to reduce the emission
of carbon dioxide for future welfare, but with the current crisis in the power sector, it has backed
off from pursuing the ambitious target of decreasing the uses of the non-renewable energy
resources to only fifty percent. This indirectly implies that in the face of the huge rise in the
prices of the electricity consumption, the consumption discount rate of the people in Australia is
expected to see an increase. The immediate implication of this dynamics is that with a soar in the
prices of gas, the residents will not agree in sacrificing their current welfare for the future
benefit, which is highly uncertain. If the present price trends continue, there can be an increase in
the demand for traditional non-renewable sources (Meng, Siriwardana & McNeill, 2013).
Figure 5: Changes in price of electricity in Australia
(Source: Smh.com.au, 2017)

15ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
The trend, as discussed above, can be interpreted in terms of general behavioral patterns
of human beings, who by nature, value current welfare that future well being because there are
more uncertainties regarding future consumption and welfare than current welfare and
consumption levels. People are risk averse by nature, barring few exceptions. This implies that
this kind of behavioral trend may be seen in this case. The uncertainties in the investment in the
power sector, as can be seen from the article, may be due to the unsure prospects and profit
abilities of these plants. Taken together, these can influence people to resort back to the usages of
non-renewable carbon emitting energy sources, even at the cost of future welfare (Smh.com.au,
2017).
Answer 5:
In the article, the term ρ, that is the time preference variable, denotes the tradeoff between
current and future preferences of the individuals. Higher the values of this variable, greater are
the preference of current consumption of an individual to future consumption. This means that a
high value of time preference for a country will cause an increase in the discount rate of
consumption for that country, which indicates that the country is more concerned with the
present welfare and bothers less about the welfare of the succeeding generations (Friedman,
2016).
The current instance of withdrawal of the United States of America from the Paris
Climate Accord can be related with the above discussion and is expected to create significant
impacts on the global environmental conditions (Bodansky, 2016).

16ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
Table 1: Average Discount Rate over the years
(Source: Americanprogress.org, 2017)
The USA has been and is still one of the highest emitters of carbon dioxide at the global
level. It contributes almost a quarter of the total emissions of carbon dioxide emission in the
world, which indirectly indicates that, the strategies and behavior of the country significantly
determines the fate of the world in terms of carbon emissions and global warming. Given this
context, the withdrawal of the country from the Climate Accord may imply that there will be less
impositions of restrictive policies and limitations on the country regarding carbon emission
(Friedman, 2016). This can increase the value of ρ, as the residents, inherently, will choose
current welfare over future welfare. This may increase the consumption discount rate of the
country and directly affect the global value of the rate by creating an upward pressure. The
global value of δ, if increases under the influence of that of the USA, can increase the threats of
global warming even more in the near future (Raupach et al, 2014).

17ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
References
Americanprogress.org. (2017). Hidden Costs: President Trump’s Campaign to Erase the Social
Cost of Carbon - Center for American Progress. Center for American Progress.
Retrieved 5 September 2017, from
https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/green/reports/2017/04/19/430591/hidden-costs-
president-trumps-campaign-erase-social-cost-carbon/
Arrow, K. J. (2007). Global climate change: A challenge to policy. The Economists' Voice, 4(3).
Bodansky, D. (2016). The Paris climate change agreement: a new hope?. American Journal of
International Law, 110(2), 288-319.
Bondyrev, I. V., Davitashvili, Z. V., & Singh, V. P. (2015). Global Warming and Climate
Change. In The Geography of Georgia (pp. 205-218). Springer International Publishing.
Climatecentral.org, J. (2017). Study Reveals Stunning Acceleration of Sea Level
Rise. Climatecentral.org. Retrieved 23 August 2017, from
http://www.climatecentral.org/news/study-reveals-acceleration-of-sea-level-rise-20055
Cook, B. I., Smerdon, J. E., Seager, R., & Coats, S. (2014). Global warming and 21st century
drying. Climate Dynamics, 43(9-10), 2607-2627.
Cropper, M. L., Freeman, M. C., Groom, B., & Pizer, W. A. (2014). Declining discount
rates. The American Economic Review, 104(5), 538-543.
Emanuel, K. (2012). What we know about climate change. MIT Press.
Fankhauser, S. (2013). Valuing climate change: the economics of the greenhouse. Routledge.

18ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
Friedlingstein, P., Andrew, R. M., Rogelj, J., Peters, G. P., Canadell, J. G., Knutti, R., ... & Le
Quéré, C. (2014). Persistent growth of CO2 emissions and implications for reaching
climate targets. Nature geoscience, 7(10), 709.
Friedman, M. (2016). A theory of the consumption function. Pickle Partners Publishing.
Goulder, L. H., & WILLIAMS III, R. C. (2012). The choice of discount rate for climate change
policy evaluation. Climate Change Economics, 3(04), 1250024.
Hansen, J., Sato, M., Hearty, P., Ruedy, R., Kelley, M., Masson-Delmotte, V., ... & Velicogna, I.
(2016). Ice melt, sea level rise and superstorms: evidence from paleoclimate data, climate
modeling, and modern observations that 2 C global warming could be
dangerous. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics, 16(6), 3761-3812.
Lau, L. C., Lee, K. T., & Mohamed, A. R. (2012). Global warming mitigation and renewable
energy policy development from the Kyoto Protocol to the Copenhagen Accord—A
comment. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 16(7), 5280-5284.
Meng, S., Siriwardana, M., & McNeill, J. (2013). The environmental and economic impact of the
carbon tax in Australia. Environmental and Resource Economics, 1-20.
O'Neill, B. C., Liddle, B., Jiang, L., Smith, K. R., Pachauri, S., Dalton, M., & Fuchs, R. (2012).
Demographic change and carbon dioxide emissions. The Lancet, 380(9837), 157-164.
Pachauri, R. K., Allen, M. R., Barros, V. R., Broome, J., Cramer, W., Christ, R., ... & Dubash, N.
K. (2014). Climate change 2014: synthesis report. Contribution of Working Groups I, II
and III to the fifth assessment report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate
Change (p. 151). IPCC.

19ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
Peters, G. P., Andrew, R. M., Boden, T., Canadell, J. G., Ciais, P., Le Quéré, C., ... & Wilson, C.
(2013). The challenge to keep global warming below 2? C. Nature Climate Change, 3(1),
4.
Raupach, M. R., Davis, S. J., Peters, G. P., Andrew, R. M., Canadell, J. G., Ciais, P., ... & Le
Quere, C. (2014). Sharing a quota on cumulative carbon emissions. Nature Climate
Change, 4(10), 873.
Rezai, A., Foley, D. K., & Taylor, L. (2016). Global warming and economic externalities. In The
Economics of the Global Environment (pp. 447-470). Springer International Publishing.
Scienceblogs.com. (2017). Denying Climate Science in Multiple Dimensions. Greg Laden's Blog.
Retrieved 23 August 2017, from http://scienceblogs.com/gregladen/2014/02/27/denying-
climate-science-in-multiple-dimensions/
Seinfeld, J. H., & Pandis, S. N. (2016). Atmospheric chemistry and physics: from air pollution to
climate change. John Wiley & Sons.
Sen, A. K. (2013). Approaches to, the Choice of Discount Rates for Social Benefit—Cost
Analysis. Discounting for Time and Risk in Energi'Policy, 325-53.
Smh.com.au, A. (2017). Wholesale power prices have doubled since the carbon tax was
axed. The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 23 August 2017, from
http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/energy-crisis-wholesale-power-
prices-have-doubled-since-the-carbon-tax-was-axed-20170308-gutf8t.html

20ECONOMICS FOR MANAGERS
Trenberth, K. E., Dai, A., Van Der Schrier, G., Jones, P. D., Barichivich, J., Briffa, K. R., &
Sheffield, J. (2014). Global warming and changes in drought. Nature Climate
Change, 4(1), 17-22.