Ethical Issues in Uzbekistan Cotton Supply

This assignment examines the complex ethical issues surrounding the cotton supply chain in Uzbekistan. It highlights the use of child and forced labor, violations of human rights, and the complicity of the clothing industry. The document proposes solutions to address these problems, including promoting media freedom, abolishing forced labor, revising wage policies, and encouraging democratic reforms in Uzbekistan.

ETHICAL DILEMMA 1
Business Ethics and Sustainability
Name
Institution
Date

ETHICAL DILEMMA 2
"Producing Toys: Child’s Play"
The product manager of a confectionery corporation seeks to make a deal with a company that is
based in Thailand for the supply of toys that the company sells. The Thailand firms give a very
attractive deal by offering prices that are two-thirds the Portuguese suppliers are offering.
However, the Thailand organization does not have an official workshop, but every morning men
collect materials, take them home to work on them together with their families. The men then
return the finished goods and collect their pay.
Following this case study, some ethical dilemmas exist. First, as a product manager, closing a
deal that will cost the company less money is a step towards minimizing operations cost. This
could earn the product manager a promotion opportunity and bonuses (Beauchamp, et al. 2004,
pg.78). However, the performance of this deal is possible at the expense of underage children
who are exploited in Thailand. Secondly, reporting the matter to the necessary authorities would
lead to penalties for the Thailand Company, and termination of the deal with the confectionery
company. Besides, it would provide no chances for promotion to the product manager. On the
contrary, reporting the matter would protect the reputation of the firm and save underage
children from exploitive activities but also affect these families’ incomes.
On a personal perspective, I would protect the rights of the minority. Besides, the deal could
have significant repercussions on the reputation of the company. Though bonuses and promotion
may not be obtained, it is legal and ethical to report the matter to Thailand’s administration. Such
exploitation of children goes against the universal rules and are at the expense of the children’s
future. Secondly, I would terminate the deal on the basis that their production methods are illegal
according to human rights. These actions will protect the company’s reputation and protect the
young children in Thailand (Johnson, 2017, Pg. 16).

ETHICAL DILEMMA 3
"Who cares who shares?"
PCC is a pharmaceutical and chemicals company that is performing well according to the stock
market records. However, recent information shows that the prices of PCC will be affected. A
company meeting provided that a scientific research had lethal outcomes. Since the finding are
set to be reported in an industry magazine, this would damage the firm and consequently lead to
the fall of PCC financials. As an employee in the company, stocks held will reduce in value and
so will those of a dear friend and his client. There are definitely ethical issues.
This case presents some ethical dilemmas and depending on the actions taken it could lead to
legal consequences. First, during the meeting to report this issue, it was asked that the matter
remain confidential and strategies formulated on how to deal with the problem. However,
remaining confidential means the dear friend and his clients will suffer significant losses once
the matter becomes public information. Secondly, as a holder of PCC stock, selling share
together with other employees could lead to suspicion and affect the company. It will also be a
case of insider trading that is punishable by law.
Therefore, on a personal perspective, my ethical solution would be retaining the information as
confidential and strategizing on how to deal with the issue as an organization (Carroll, and
Buchholtz, 2014, pg. 105). First, I would propose the termination of the drug with lethal side-
effects should cease. However, losses will be incurred. As a person, selling the shares will save
me a lot of money but with the risk of being charged with insider trading (Crane, and Matten,
2016, pg. 64). Telling my friend would also have similar effects. Though remaining quiet may
affect the friendship, it is the ethical thing to do. I would develop strategies to sustain the
reputation of the company may help regain the value of the shares.

ETHICAL DILEMMA 4
"Off your face on Facebook",
As a human resource manager, the task of recruiting personnel falls under this job description.
At AllCure pharmaceuticals, the human resource manager needs to hire a new team member to
fill a position in the clinical trials department. Luckily, two applicants have qualifications
making them equally suitable for the job. However, after social media research, one of the
applicants has an incriminating social media page. Her page shows that she has taken illegal
drugs and some photos of her are taken while partially naked. This situation raises some ethical
dilemmas for the HR manager.
Using social media to screen applicant is considered risky and quite unethical. This is because it
involves invading the applicants’ privacy and the information gathered may create a biased
opinion about the applicants. Nonetheless, for justifiable reasons such as participating in illegal
activities could form a basis for disqualifying a candidate using social media (Ferrell, and
Fraedrich, 2015, pg. 165). In this case, the ethical dilemmas related to wrongful disqualification
and protecting the reputation of the company. Disqualify the candidate with an incriminating
Facebook page is unethical as her personal issues lack adverse impacts on others. However, her
former actions will implicate the company’s image.
On a personal viewpoint, I would place the two applicants on probation. This gives both
candidates equal opportunities to prove their value to the company on a leveled platform. It will
also provide an opportunity to gain an unbiased opinion of the applicant with an implicating
Facebook page (Kluemper, 2013, pg. 13). Nonetheless, I would develop strategies to remove
those pictures and discussed them with the candidate to ensure that she approves. As such, the
company will not only observe their capabilities first-hand but also examines their abilities to
relate to people within the organization and contribute to teamwork. After the probation period,

ETHICAL DILEMMA 5
the candidate with better performance and who is also best suited should be chosen to fill the
position. It will also ensure that the operations of the clinical trials are not stalled (Melanthiou,
Pavlou, and Constantinou, 2015. Pg. 43).
"Organic Food - what's an 'organic' label worth?"
There is an increasing demand for organic products globally. However, the production of organic
foods takes almost twice as much land and effort as using conventional methods. Though
consumers are willing to pay for these premium products, the supply can barely meet the
demand. In the USA and Europe alone, up to ninety percent of the population demands organic
products. Consequently, these governments have supply labels to protect consumers and only
give an allowance of 95% organic. Nevertheless, ethical problems have been encountered. They
range from shell companies supplying counterfeit labels to farmers to companies replacing
organic ingredients with inorganic ones.
A number of ethical issues have to be considered. First, consumers have inferior information to
corporations and can only rely on the integrity of the government. Misleading advertisements
such as using counterfeit labels and altering ingredients affect consumer choices. Besides, some
countries such as China and Italy have been found in grave misconduct. Fraud cases have been
encountered with conventional products being relabeled as organic (Nuttavuthisit, and
Thøgersen, 2017, pg. 325). On the other hand, it is less expensive to grow conventional products
than organic. The former requires less space while the latter, however, has an adverse impact on
the environment.
On a personal perspective, I would advises companies to avoid fraudulent behavior by reporting
the correct information relating to the ingredients in their products. Secondly, I would place

ETHICAL DILEMMA 6
stringent measures on countries using banned pesticides to grow their products. Thirdly, I would
advise the government to implement procedures to determine the nature of the products offered
to the society by ensuring integrity in the offices that provide these labels (Vitell, and Hunt,
2015, pg. 22). In the meantime, new methods of dealing with climatic issues should be
developed. Agroforestry should be employed to solve the problems that may arise such as cutting
down of trees.
"Uzbek Cotton: a new spin on responsible sourcing"
Cotton is a common raw material in the manufacturing of clothes. This raw material is sourced
from different nations. However, the supply of cotton has been associated with cases of child and
forced labor coupled with poor working conditions. Uzbekistan is one of the leading countries
that supply cotton worldwide. It is also reported to exploit children and adults in the harvest of
cotton. Most importantly, the government forces its people to harvest cotton, pay low wages and
official reap most of the benefits. Since government action was not possible, international
organization resulted in compelling the buyers of cotton, clothing companies, to boycott
Uzbekistan cotton. This was initially met with resistance and denial of any knowledge of human
rights violations (Kolk, 2016, pg.32).
Following the facts of this case, numerous ethical issues arise. First, the cotton supply chain is
compromised. The buyers of cotton mix their products making it a challenge to trace the origin
of cotton. Boycotting Uzbekistan cotton reduces cotton supply and affects revenues for the
buyers raising ethical dilemmas. Secondly, the supply of cotton from Uzbekistan relies on child
and forced labor. This is a violation of human rights. The working conditions are poor and the
wages paid are low. For Uzbekistan government, ethical dilemmas lie between revenues and the

ETHICAL DILEMMA 7
exploitation of citizens (Donnelly, 2013, pg. 21). Lastly, the clothing industry claims to have no
knowledge of the issue, yet they benefit from countries using forced labor to supply cotton.
Based on the above ethical problems, I would install measures that are appropriate in the
protection of Uzbekistan citizens. However, I would work with international organizations to
influence a change in the administration of Uzbekistan. The government should increase media
freedom and abolish forced and child labor. Additionally, the wage rate policy should be revised
to distribute more money to the people rather than corrupt officials. Besides, the country should
embrace democracies (Tomuschat, 2014, pg. 16). These approaches should solve the ethical
issues relating to cotton supply.

ETHICAL DILEMMA 8
Bibliography
Beauchamp, T.L., Bowie, N.E. and Arnold, D.G. eds., 2004. Ethical theory and business.
Carroll, A. and Buchholtz, A., 2014. Business and society: Ethics, sustainability, and stakeholder
management. Nelson Education.
Crane, A. and Matten, D., 2016. Business ethics: Managing corporate citizenship and
sustainability in the age of globalization. Oxford University Press.
Donnelly, J., 2013. Universal human rights in theory and practice. Cornell University Press.
Ferrell, O.C. and Fraedrich, J., 2015. Business ethics: Ethical decision making & cases. Nelson
Education.
Johnson, C.E., 2017. Meeting the ethical challenges of leadership: Casting light or shadow. Sage
Publications.
Kluemper, D.H., 2013. Social network screening: pitfalls, possibilities, and parallels in
employment selection. In Social media in human resources management. (pp. 1-21). Emerald
Group Publishing Limited.
Kolk, A., 2016. The social responsibility of international business: From ethics and the
environment to CSR and sustainable development. Journal of World Business, 51(1), pp.23-34.
Melanthiou, Y., Pavlou, F. and Constantinou, E., 2015. The use of social network sites as an e-
recruitment tool. Journal of Transnational Management, 20(1), pp.31-49.
Nuttavuthisit, K. and Thøgersen, J., 2017. The importance of consumer trust for the emergence
of a market for green products: The case of organic food. Journal of Business Ethics, 140(2),
pp.323-337.

ETHICAL DILEMMA 9
Tomuschat, C., 2014. Human rights: between idealism and realism. OUP Oxford.
Vitell, S.J. and Hunt, S.D., 2015. The general theory of marketing ethics: the consumer ethics
and intentions issues. Handbook on ethics and marketing, pp.15-37.