Critical Appraisal of a Published Systematic Review on Obesity

Critical appraisal litrature review critique a published aystematic review

Table of Contents
Question 1) Review purpose and objective of questions..........................................................................3
Question 2) Published protocol for the review.........................................................................................3
Question 3) Eligibility criteria for the purpose of review........................................................................3
Question 4) Type of study in the review..................................................................................................3
Question 5) Data base and search engine related to review.....................................................................4
Question 6) Suitability of search terms:...................................................................................................4
Question 7) Discuss Search limits that were applied...............................................................................4
Question 8) Assesment of PRISMA Flow chart:.....................................................................................4
Question 9) Discuss Instruments used to determine methodological quality of articles...........................4
Question 10) Does given study summarized in an adequate manner.......................................................5
Question 11) Are excluded studies listed with relevant reason of exclusion............................................5
Question 12) Discuss the way by which data is abstracted and synthesized................................................5
Question 13) Does adequate critique of studies reviewed that include discussion of study limitations. . .5
Question 14) What is your assessment related to level of evidence included in the review.....................6
Question 15) How should this information can be applied in clinical practice........................................6

Question 1) Review purpose and objective of questions
It is analyzed that main purpose of this review is to monitor the reason of obesity within
individuals. Here, obesity has become a crucial problem among people nowadays. Main reason
behind this is the unhealthy lifestyle and food. Here, several preventions need to undertake by
government and regional agencies in order to control the problem of obesity within individuals
of country. It is analyzed that childhood obesity has become a major problem nowadays that
need to be addressed in an efficient manner (Booth, Sutton and Papaioannou, 2016).
Question 2) Published protocol for the review
Here published protocol refers to a record of plan of actions prepared by researcher,
detailing related to advance study, analysis as well as methodology (Carter, Creedy and
Sidebotham, 2016). It is monitored that there is no published protocol for this review. It may
help to carry out whole discussion in more better and effective way.
Question 3) Eligibility criteria for the purpose of review
There are several eligibility criteria have been followed in the present report. Inclusion
criteria for present research are overweight, obesity prevention and intervention, mental health
measure and more. On the basis of these factors there are ample of people have included in
report. (Christofi, Leonidou and Vrontis, 2017). In addition, there are some exclusion criteria
have been also followed in present report. Exclusion criteria’s are obesity treatment,
management, focus on high risk and more. So, it is crucial to follow proper criteria for inclusion
and exclusion that will help to get appropriate conclusion out of research.
Question 4) Type of study in the review
It is monitored that there are different types of studies that are used by researcher in order
to egt appropriate information (Deshpande and et. al., 2017). Different type of studies include
randomize control trials, quasi experimental and natural experimental. For current research
randomize control trials are used in which objectives have been randomly assigned to one of two
groups. Here, one is experimental and other one is conventional group.