Organisational Behaviour: Motivation, Failure, Learning, Improvement

This report explores key concepts in organisational behaviour, including organisational structures, motivation, learning from failure, and performance improvement. It examines the structures of Microsoft and Valve, highlighting the effectiveness of stack ranking and the challenges of multitasking. The report also discusses motivation strategies at General Mills Canada and the elements used by Engstrom Auto Mirror and analyzes Morgan Stanley's performance appraisal plan, along with the advantages and disadvantages of Deloitte's employee evaluation methods. The analysis incorporates various organisational behaviour theories to provide a comprehensive understanding of how organisations function and how employees can be motivated and managed effectively. Desklib provides a platform for students to access similar solved assignments and study resources.

Organisational Behaviour
1

Table of Contents
Introduction.................................................................................................................................................3
Task 1: Why do organizations exist?...........................................................................................................4
Task 2. How do people make the place?......................................................................................................7
Task 3. How do we motivate others and ourselves?..................................................................................10
Task 4. How do we fail, learn, and improve?............................................................................................13
Conclusion.................................................................................................................................................16
References.................................................................................................................................................17
2

Introduction
In this study, the structures, forms and organisational design and their effectiveness have been
studied and the examples of Microsoft and Valve have been taken to illustrate the success of
implementing the stack system. The problems related to multitasking Valve have also been
evaluated. The different types of motivation provided by General Mills Canada and the
importance of providing motivation have also been discussed. The elements used by Engstrom
Auto Mirror have been discussed and in the last part, the performance appraisal plan developed
by Morgan Stanley has been discussed along with the advantages and disadvantages of the
methods used by Deloitte while evaluating the performance of its employees.
3

Task 1: Why do organizations exist?
Microsoft was started with the idea of developing technology which involves huge capital and
over a period of time the company had expanded its operations. Due to the scale of its operations
and revenues generated, the company provided huge incentives and the company also provided
stock options scheme to its employees in order to motivate them. Also, the expectations of the
shareholders have to be met and hence, it resulted in providing dividends and bonus share which
affected the revenue generation and profit marginalisation. Hence, Microsoft concentrated on
providing the benefits to the employees so that long-term association of them can be ensured and
talent can be retained within the company. The structure of the company also changed over a
period of time because of large-scale innovation program initiated by the company and creating
sub-units to manage them which resulted in forming a complicated company structure
(Eichenwald, 2012).
On the other hand, Valve was able to successfully implement the stack ranking because the
company used all its resources to innovate and hence, the selection criteria of the employees
enabled the company to hire passionate and talented employees. There are no external investors
and hence, there is no pressure on the shareholders to provide returns or bargain the amount of
dividend that has to be declared by the company. Valve has adopted the stack ranking in
providing financial benefits to its employees based on the judgement provided by the managers
and also, forming the criteria for deciding the compensation based on the output which enables
effective control of operations.
4

Microsoft was one of the leading organisations in the past decade which created various systems
and provided varieties of software. However, due to the change in the technology and formation
of new companies increased the competition and affected the growth and development of the
company. The competitors such as Dell were able to capitalise on this and were able to increase
their presence this led to the declining sales of the products designed by Microsoft. There are
multiple investors who expect to get a fair share on their investments and hence, there is an
increased pressure to retain the market share in order to maintain the goodwill and reputation of
the company (Rusu and Avasilcai, 2014).
The company management develops plans to retain the market share instead of finding new
avenues which can help the company to innovate and diversify the products and services
provided to the customers. Innovation helps the company to grow but finding other opportunities
reduces the pressure on the management to generate more revenues from few operations. This
approach led to the downfall of Microsoft and reduced its market share.
Multitasking involves performing different jobs and contains multiple components of a particular
task that has to be performed. The idea is to reduce the costs of production by reducing the
number of employees required to perform the job and the tasks are allocated to the employees
based on their skill and abilities. This ensures that the quality output can be provided at the
reduced costs and Valve will be benefited by developing multitasking strategies in its operations.
Valve plans to increase its operations by developing hardware components which ensure its
continued growth and development (Becker, et. al., 2013).
5

However, there may be few issues related to multitasking that the management has to overcome
and the main issue is that employees will not be able to innovate and develop new products since
their primary concern will be to complete the tasks that have been assigned to them. The quality
of the output may also get affected since the employees may not be able to allocate sufficient
time for performing the tasks efficiently which increases the workload of quality checking team
since every task has to be properly monitored. The other major factor that may affect the quality
of the output is that employees may concentrate only on those tasks which may provide good
ratings during the performance evaluation process. Hence, all these factors may affect the
performance of the employees and Valve may have to incur huge costs for implementing
effective control measures. The company management has to consider all these factors while
expanding its operations and develop new strategies in order to be successful in its new projects
(Mosow, 2014).
In order to develop a successful strategy, Valve can implement the change theories implemented
by ASDA known as Theories E and O. The goals have to be defined based on the market
research, expectations of the stakeholders and the company’s abilities in performing the tasks.
After defining the goals and objectives, the management structure should be so designed in
which the delegation of authority is done at the top and targets are assigned to the different
teams. By developing this approach, Valve will be able to implement the change strategies
effectively which ensures greater participation of employees and increased coordination among
the teams. While delegating the targets, proper market research has to be conducted so that the
realistic and achievable goals can be set (Schwartz, et. al., 2012).
6

Task 2. How do people make the place?
General Mills is one of the leading companies which deal with providing varieties of food
products for the people around the globe. The company employs more than 38,000 employees
across the globe and has various brands such as Cheerios, Betty Crocker, Pillsbury, Annie’s,
Haagen-Dazs and Cascadian Farm. The president of the company, David Homer, is on a mission
to change the outlook of the company and promote innovation within the organisation, however,
due to the collegial atmosphere, the new strategy has to be developed by taking the support and
consensus from the stakeholders. This hampers the process of change in the organisation and
which results in maintaining the conservative approach of management (McLaren and Mills,
2015).
David Homer observed that even though the company is generating revenues, the employees lack
motivation and a general lack of initiative. The employees do not have a proper channel to
express their views and opinion and hence, the company lacks in developing new technologies.
The primary focus of the management should be to encourage the employees to participate in the
meetings and discussion. The management should create platforms where the ideas can be
discussed and practically implemented which will helps in the development of the company.
General Mills should devise the policies such that the decision-making process is more
transparent and employees can be involved while deciding the course of the business. The
company can also plan training and development of employees which ensures that the employees
have required knowledge and expertise, as well as they are motivated to perform better and
achieve their targets (Mitchell and Mark, 2014).
7

The organisational structure should be designed which promotes coordination and cooperation
among the employees and the hierarchies should define the flow of communication. The
management can develop the organisation structure based on the top-down approach in which
the targets are decided by the top management and the teams are assigned with the specific
targets that are to be achieved for over a specific period of time. Also, the regular feedback has to
be taken to ensure that the desired targets are achieved and hence, follow-up action has to be
based on bottom-up approach. The issues encountered by the teams have to be discussed with top
management so that appropriate solutions can be implemented.
The changes in the whole system enable the employees to perform the tasks depending on the
change that has been initiated and hence, employees will be able to perform better. By
developing incentive plans, the management motivates the employees to perform better which
results in enhanced productivity and quality of the work performed. All these factors ensure that
General Mills will be able to compete in the competitive market scenario (Foss, et. al., 2013).
There are four types of organisational structure that can be developed by the company as per
Robert E Quinn and Kim S Cameron. These four types can be evaluated as Clan, Adhocracy,
Market, and Hierarchy. These structures are designed by the promoters depending on the nature
and size of the business and also, the level of flexibility that is required to perform the various
activities smoothly and effectively.
8

As per the above organisational structures, General Mills Canada has a ‘Hierarchy’ type of
organisational structure where the decisions are taken in consultation with other stakeholders.
The targets are defined based on the complete analysis of the market and by understanding the
tastes and preferences of the customers. Also, the ways in which the tasks have to be performed
are pre-defined and there are control measures that are placed in order to increase the
productivity of the employees. In order to promote innovation, the company has to change its
structure to “Adhocracy” in which the focus should be on improving the techniques and
promoting innovation in all the activities (Ahmadi, et. al., 2012).
Innovation can be promoted by providing flexibility to the employees and developing suitable
platforms for the employees to share their ideas. Accountability for the job ensures that
employees are aware of their roles and responsibilities and hence, it has to be practiced to
develop a professional environment in the company. However, independence of thought and the
different ways of achieving the targets have to be practiced so that, the employees innovate new
techniques while considering to complete their tasks which ensures improved efficiency and
effectiveness in the output. Also, taking regular feedback of the tasks performed by the
employees helps to monitor their progress and provide suitable rewards in order to motivate the
employees to perform better. This ensures General Mills will be able to achieve the overall
targets as well as promote innovation within the organisation. This helps the company to keep
pace with the changing market conditions (Ahmadi, et. al., 2012).
9

Task 3. How do we motivate others and ourselves?
Motivation involves developing external and internal factors within the organisation to stimulate
the employees to perform better. This ensures achieving overall goals and objectives of the
company. As per Locke and Latham (2002), there is a direct relationship between motivation and
performance and hence, achievable goals have to be provided to the employees in order to
enhance their motivation level. Hence, goal-setting is the first priority taken by the authors while
providing the elements of motivation. It is also argued that providing the higher targets increases
the expectancy and employees improve their performance to achieve their targets (Rusu and
Avasilcai, 2014).
There are four goal mechanisms which have been considered by the authors, namely, setting the
goals or targets provides the required direction and focus on performing the activities which
direct towards achieving goals. The second is the energising function, as per which, delegating
higher targets results in greater efforts than delegating relatively smaller objectives. The third
mechanism is persistence, where the difficult tasks enable the teams to perform faster and there
is no wastage of time. The last is that goals affect action and employees use their knowledge and
expertise to achieve their targets (Otmakhova, et. al., 2013).
In the Engstrom Auto Mirror case, the morale of the employees who were working with
Engstrom Auto Mirror was very low and hence, the plant faced a crisis of low productivity and
issue related to the culture practiced in the company. Employees did not support the incentive
plan formulated by the company and hence, a general feeling of distrust was developed towards
the management. Hence, Ron Bent, the manager of the firm, decided to implement Scanlon Plan
to motivate the employees as well as to increase the productivity of the employees.
10

This plan considers taking support from the employees and hence, this ensures participation of
the employees in the managerial decision-making process. The suggestions provided by the
employees are discussed at the management level and there is a periodical review system which
helps the employees to know the actual revenues earned by the company. Hence, the process is
transparent and there is no bias in the system.
However, there are other factors which were not considered by Engstrom Auto Mirror such as
developing performance evaluation plan, providing facilities to employees such as medical
facilities, loan facilities at a lower interest and conducting various employee-centric activities
such as arranging tours for the employees. All these activities enhance the loyalty of the
employees towards the management and motivate them to perform better targets (Rusu and
Avasilcai, 2014).
The Scanlon Plan adopted by Engstrom Auto Mirror may fail because of the factors such as, the
management may announce a project and set a deadline for the project, however, these projects
may require huge efforts which results in producing the sub-standard quality of work. The setting
of narrow goals results in ignoring the safety standards which may result in failure of the
product. The employees may take too much risk and may ignore the general guidelines
formulated by the company to protect the interests of the employees. The unscientific goal
setting may also result in unethical behaviour and employees may resort to cheat or falsify their
achieved targets in order to get more incentives and rewards. This creates a negative working
environment within the company.
11

Monetary benefit is the important factor which motivates the employees to perform better and
hence, the companies formulate the policies aiming at providing incentives and bonus to enhance
their performance. The incentive plans enable the management to plan and devise the
performance evaluation methodology and ensures that the talents are recognised and rewarded.
Even though monetary benefits stimulate the employees and increase efficiency and productivity
in the organisation, employees expect a few facilities from the management such as medical care,
transport, and others, depending on the nature of the business. Hence, providing only monetary
benefits may not suffice and management will have to combine other non-monetary factors along
with the incentive plan (Mosow, 2014).
Along with implementing the Scanlon Plan, the management should have provided medical
insurance to the employees so that they feel safe and secure while working in Engstrom Auto
Mirror. Also, the other facilities such as free lunch and free transport facilities should have been
implemented which enhances the loyalty of the employees towards the company. The incentive
plan should have been scientifically designed in order to ascertain the individual performances.
The management should also ascertain the level of knowledge of each employee and to design
the training programmes after ascertaining the gaps in the performance. All these factors enhance
the cooperation and coordination among the employees and results in improved efficiency of the
production. By acquiring knowledge, the employees will be able to enhance their career
prospects both within and outside Engstrom Auto Mirror.
12