What is the evidence for psychological therapies other than Cognitive Behaviour Therapy in autism and cooccurring disorders?

What is the evidence for psychological therapies
other than Cognitive Behaviour Therapy in autism
and co-occurring disorders? A systematic review.

Contents
Abstract............................................................................................................................................................3
Introduction......................................................................................................................................................3
Methods............................................................................................................................................................6
Systematic search and Eligibility......................................................................................................................6
Data extraction.................................................................................................................................................7
Results.............................................................................................................................................................. 7
Discussion......................................................................................................................................................25
Conclusion......................................................................................................................................................28
References......................................................................................................................................................30
APPENDIX....................................................................................................................................................34

Abstract
Individuals with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) are more susceptible to stress, anxiety and depression
than typically developing individuals. Previous research suggests that Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (CBT) is
effective in reducing a myriad of psychological health problems in a wide variety of populations. However,
research identified other psychotherapies that might be just as effective as Cognitive Behaviour Therapy
(CBT). However, it has been analysed that Cognitive Behaviour Therapy is not that much effective for every
single individual therefore, it is needed to conduct investigation to identify the best suitable therapy to serve
individuals dealing with Autism and Co-occurring disorders. This review systematically investigated the
efficacy of Animal-Assisted Therapy (AAT). Dance/Movement Therapy (DMT), Program for the Education
and Enrichment of Relational Skills (PEERS), and Mindfulness-based therapy (MBT) interventions in
reducing anxiety and depression in individuals with ASD. Fourteen studies met inclusion criteria. Results
indicate that the above-named psychotherapies reduce anxiety and depression in, children, adolescents,
young adults, and adults with autism. Additionally, some of the interventions identified reduced core autism
symptoms and improved overall quality of life. Therefore, considering different interventions like
Dance/Movement Therapy (DMT), Achievement Anxiety Test (AAT), Mindfulness-based therapy (MBT),
Program for the Education and Enrichment of Relational Skills (PEERS) and other would effectively lead
individuals dealing with autism and co-occurring disorders to gain positive changes in both mental and
physical conditions. Future research should address the methodological limitations of the studies in this
review to develop superior interventions that are to be considered evidence-based practice aimed at
enhancing the quality of life of individuals with ASD.
Introduction
Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD or autism) is a neuro developmental disorder characterized by
impairments in speech, social communication, social functioning, and repetitive or stereotyped behaviour
(Lai et al., 2019; Hossain et al., 2020). This is an neurodevelopmentalal disorder and symptoms usually
appear in the first two years of life, although may not become obvious until social demands outweigh
capacity (Hepburn et al., 2014; Hofyander et al., 2009; Maddox et al., 2015). The most recent measurements
indicate that approximately 1% of the global population hold an autism diagnosis (Lai et al., 2019; Lyall et
al., 2017, Hossain et al., 2020).
It has been widely accepted that individuals with autism develop co-occurring mental health (MH)
conditions. Figures show that 70% of individuals on the autism spectrum develop at least one cooccurring
MH condition, with at least 50% of individuals developing two or more (Hossain et al., 2020; Lai,

Lombardo, & Baron-Cohen, 2014; Ameis & Szatmari, 2015). However, the above mentioned information
specifically varies from area to area (geographical locations). One of the most recent systematic reviews in
the field, reported that the pooled prevalence is 28% for ADHD, 20% for anxiety disorders, 13% for sleep-
wake disorders, 12% for disruptive, impulsive-control, and conduct disorders, 1% for depressive disorders,
9% for obsessive-compulsive disorder, 5% for bipolar disorders, and 4% for schizophrenia disorders (Lai et
al., 2019).
Arguably, the most prevalent MH conditions among the autistic population are anxiety and
depressive disorders (Uljarevic et al., 2019; Mazzone et al., 2012). On the other hand, as mentioned above
approximately 13% of autistic population is dealing with sleep-wake disorders, around 12% of the
individuals are going through disruptive, conduct disorders and impulsive-control, 1% for depressive
disorders, 9% for obsessive-compulsive disorder. Therefore, it can easily be said that these predict lower
quality of life, increased service use, significant impairment in adaptive, family, academic, and social
functioning (Olatunji, Eklund, & Howley, 2007; Cadman et al., 2012; Joshi et al., 2012; Higa-McMillan et
al., 2018). According to Uljarevic et al., 2016 and van Steensel et al., 2011 around 40% of youth (children
and adolescents) diagnosed with autism develop anxiety disorders. This rate is higher compared to the
general population (Gadow et al., 2005) but also higher compared to other neurodevelopmental disorders
(Rodgers et al., 2012). Research on adults on the spectrum suggest that around 53.6% meet the diagnostic
symptoms for clinical anxiety (Buck et al., 2014; Lever & Geurts, 2016; Roy et al., 2015), whereas only 35%
meet the diagnostic criteria for symptoms of depression or depressive disorders (Cassidy et al., 2014; Russell
et al., 2015; Wigham et al., 2017).
Given the regularity with which anxiety and depression co-occur in ASD, in combination with their
effect on functioning, quality of life, and adult outcome, it is important to consider how best to prevent and
manage these disorders among adults and children with ASD (Higa-McMillan et al., 2018). To date, and
recommended by NICE (2013), the most used treatments are talk therapy, such as Cognitive Behavioural
Therapy (CBT) (Propper & Orlik, 2014; Williams, Wheeler, Silove, & Hazell, 2010) and psychotropic
medication (Lake et al., 2015; Maddox et al., 2018).
CBT assumes that cognitive factors support psychological distress and MH disorders, and that
challenging behaviour and emotional distress are maintained by maladaptive cognitions, such as general
beliefs about the self, the world, and the future. CBT sessions are carried out individually (Thyme et al.,
2006; Beebe, Gelfant, & Bender, 2010), in group (Gold, Wigram, & Elefant, 2006) or a mix between group
and individual sessions (Keng, Smiski, & Robins, 2011). During treatment, therapists are challenging these
maladaptive cognitions to change the associated beliefs and thoughts, and trialling new behavioural
approaches to ultimately reduce the symptoms, improve functioning, and prevent remission of the disorder
(Hoffman et al., 2012). Hence, the patient assumes the role of a decision-maker in a problem-solving
situation where they challenge and test the authenticity of their maladaptive cognitions and adjust

challenging behaviour patterns. Thus, CBT creates a model of intervention by combining cognitive,
behavioural, and emotion-focused techniques (Hoffman, 2011).
Including this, the best evidence for CBT has been found as an intervention for anxiety disorders
(Casidy, Bradley, Shaw, & Baron-Cohen 2018) and found moderate to large effect sizes (Ben-Sasson et al.,
2008; Kim, Szatmari, Bryson, Streiner, & Wilson, 2000; Mayes, Calhoun, Murray, & Zahid, 2011). Parents
of children with ASD reported an improvement in anxiety symptoms (Danial and Wood, 2013; Wood,
Drahota, & Sze, 2009; Wood, Fujii, & Renno, 2011). There is also some evidence that the same
improvement was observed in adults on the spectrum (Cardaciotto and Herbert, 2004; Weiss and Lunsky,
2010). A recent meta-analysis reported a small to medium treatment effect for management of comorbid
affective disorders in ASD (Weston, Hodgekins, & Langdon, 2016). Surprisingly, one quasi-experimental
design study reported a positive outcome on depression, but no effect was reported on anxiety (McGillivray
and Evert, 2014).
On the other hand, most autistic individuals (both children and adults) with co-occurring anxiety
and/or depression are readily prescribed psychotropic and antidepressant medication or benzodiazepine
(Rosenberg et al. 2010; Coury et al. 2012; Logan et al. 2012; Memari et al. 2012; Schubart et al. 2013;
Spencer et al. 2013; Hsia et al. 2014). By the time they reach adulthood, around 75% of children and
adolescents on the spectrum have already been prescribed psychotropic medication (Esbensen et al. 2009;
Spencer et al. 2013). The study of Maddox et al., (2018), comprising of 268 individuals with ASD (age
range: 18-65 years), reported that 51.1% were taking antidepressant medication, 39.6% antipsychotic
medication, and 28.0% benzodiazepine. Furthermore, an online survey (Gotham et al., 2015) stated that out
of 255 adults who self-reported their treatment 61% were taking medication, and out of 143 adults whose
information about treatment was provided by their caregivers, 72% were taking medication.
Anxiety is considered to be one of the most common disorder which can be identified in teenagers where,
ASD and Core Social Disability among them can easily be treated in much effective and in efficient manner
considering combined treatment approaches. It has been analysed that, randomized controlled trial has given
ample number of benefits to evaluate, pull out feasible information and preliminary outcomes considering
Multimodal Anxiety and Social Skills Intervention (MASSI) program. Including this, it can be said that the
treatment considering the MASSI Program it was pretty much acceptable to both autistic population and
families as well. Approximately 16% of the improvement can be seen within Autism spectrum disorder
considering social impairment. Due to the particular intervention, anxiety symptoms declined by 26 %.
However, it can be said that these alterations are not statistically significant. Therefore, it cannot be said that
if MASSI is an effective program to treat individuals dealing with ASD. Away with this, CBT and
psychotropic medication have been found to not be effective for every autistic individual. Moreover, CBT is
not the only psychological therapy recommended for the same mental health conditions (White et al., 2018).

Research Aim: The aim of the present systematic review is “To identify and evaluate the existing
evidence base for psychological therapies used in the treatment of co-occurring MH conditions in autistic
population.”
Research Objectives:
 To understand the concept of autism and co-occurring disorders.
 To identify the different psychological therapies used in the treatment of co-occurring MH
conditions in autistic population.
 To analyse the benefits of using various therapies like Animal-assisted therapy (AAT), Dance-
Movement Therapy (DMT), Program for the Education and Enrichment of Relational Skills
(PEERS), and Mindfulness based stress reduction therapy (MBSR) while treating Autism and co-
occurring disorders.
The particular focus is on psychological therapies used in the treatment of anxiety and depression
disorders. Different psychotherapies, such as animal-assisted therapy, dance-movement therapy (DMT),
Program for the Education and Enrichment of Relational Skills (PEERS) and Mindfulness based stress
reduction therapy (MBSR) have been identified. These studies reported improvements in anxiety and
depressive symptoms among the autistic population. Although small, the body of research on DMT argues
that such therapy has a positive impact on lowering depression and anxiety symptoms and improving social
functioning for both children and adults (Dunphy, Mullane, & Jacobsson, 2013). Keng et al., (2011)
reviewed 16 RCTs on mindfulness and its impact on the autism spectrum and highlighted substantial
improvement in positive affect, empathy, and quality of life.
Methods
Systematic search and Eligibility
In order to identify the studies, several literature searches have been performed in the following
databases: Embase, PsycInfo, and Medline. Search included key words such as autism (and auti*), treatment,
management, psychotherapy (and psychotherap*), anxiety, depression, MH, children, youth, adolescents,
and adults. These words were also combined to better the database search. For any study to be included, it
had to meet the following criteria: Studies to be in English Language, Studies to be published between 2008
and 2020. The reason that came in front of considering publications from 2008 is because from overall
estimated prevalence of Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD or autism) among the 14 ADDM sites was 11.3 per
1,000 (one in 88) children aged 8 years who were living in these communities during 2008. Away with this,
the last date of data which is being gathered is the May month ending of 2020.
All studies had to include children or adolescents or Adults, Studies to look at psychological
treatment of comorbid anxiety or Depression, Studies published only in peer review Journals Participants

within the identified studies had to have an autism diagnosis. On the other hand, those individuals will not be
considered who are already dealing with chronic diseases. Before going ahead and including the final studies
in the review, a list of 50 and 100 study titles along with the inclusion criteria were checked by supervisor
and peers as an extra form of database search validation. Including this, consent form is also going to be
given to them in order to keep up their trust and reduce any risks of disagreement and so on.
Data extraction
For each included study, a data extraction form was put in place. The form included details such as
participant demographics (number of participants included in each study, age range, no of males and
females, and descriptive statistics), methods (aim of the study, intervention type, duration of participation),
and procedure (duration and frequency of treatment, and assessment tools used). This information along with
the study characteristics (such as author, year, and title) can be found in Table 1.
Quality Rating (With 5 being the highest)
Age range 3
no of males and females 4
descriptive statistics 5
Results
Study selection
The total number of references identified through database search is 529 and after duplicates were
removed, 331 studies were screened against the eligibility criteria. Studies were excluded initially based on
title, and subsequently some full text studies were also excluded. Factors determining the exclusion of
studies are related to reasons such as the target sample was not autistic population, and the intervention was
not targeting anxiety or depression, but rather cognitive systems or motor skills. Studies that targeted social
functioning and social skills were included. The final sample included 14 studies – 4 studies were Animal-
Assisted Intervention, 1 study was a Dance-Movement intervention, 4 studies were PEERS intervention, and
5 studies were MBT intervention. The PRISMA flowchart (Moher et al., 2009; Liberati et al., 2009) of the
systematic search results and the included studies is presented in Fig 1.