Table of Contents INTRODUCTION:..........................................................................................................................1 TASK1.............................................................................................................................................1 P1.Analyse impact and influence of macro environment of Uber technologies and also its strategies......................................................................................................................................1 TASK2.............................................................................................................................................3 P2.Examine intrinsic environment and capabilities of Uber Technologies by using appropriate frameworks.................................................................................................................................3 TASK 3.........................................................................................................................................6 P3: Applying Porter's five force model to evaluate competitive forces of Uber:.......................6 TASK4.............................................................................................................................................8 P4: Describe theories and strategic business plan.......................................................................8 CONCLUSION.............................................................................................................................11 REFERENCES..............................................................................................................................12
INTRODUCTION: Business Strategy can be defined as group of decision or course of action which serve entrepreneurs in achievement of business objectives. It is a master plan by which management of organisation execute to secure a position in market segment, by carry on its operation, customer satisfaction and achieved desired goals of business. It can be termed as backbone of organisation because it provides road map to achieve desired objectives. Uber Technologies Inc. is an American company which offers vehicles for food delivery, hire, courier, package delivery, freight transportation services to business operations and general people. It also have partnership with motorised scooter rental, lime, electric bicycle for satisfy customer needs. Headquarter of company is in San Francisco, California, U.S., operated in over 900 metropolitan areas worldwide. Uber has estimation of over 110 million monthly active end users all over world(Ostos, Hinderer and Bravo, 2017). This report covers internal and macro analysis of Uber technologies by covering strength and weakness of company also opportunities for firm to attain future growth. In addition, Porter's five forces and Generic strategies are also discussed with suitable plan. TASK1 P1.Analyse impact and influence of macro environment of Uber technologies and also its strategies. Pestle Analysis is a techniques to examine key factors such as Political, Economic, Social, Technological, Legal, Environmental factors which influence organisation from outside. By this, it allows senior managers and HR to evaluate any risks which are related to their industry and company, use these knowledge to inform decisions. By this, there is a huge impact on position of company in existing industry or future growth in many countries. Pestle Analysis of Uber Technologies are discussed below:ï‚·Political Factor:These forces is all about degree of government which are involve in economy. This element include tax policy, environmental law, political stability. In context of Uber technologies, it enjoy political factor as by government concentration which offers favour to company. But it has also sustain negative impact by factor as there are many strict rules and regulation for documentation and licensing are implemented by government. This leads to creation of opportunities for growth and long term feasibility 1
of business.In addition, Uber has faced controversy in market segment. As it have not clear rules and regulations. So it leads to drawback for company because there is no record of accidents. Furthermore, company also face problem as France filed against company which is based on advertising. In addition, there is also political discussion about minimum wage rate system in industries which is related taxi. So government have to requires license according to requirement of documentation.ï‚·Economic Factor: These factors have serious impact on organisation that how they do their business and also profitability of work. It includes elements such as inflations, economic growth, interest rates, exchange rates and so on. Industry in which Uber is functioning sharing economy. It means that, this economy is mainly based on sharing intellectual or physical resources. In US, rates of policies are adequate which provides support in smooth functioning of performance of company. Consumers are also enjoy their premium services which leads to increase in profitability of business and also create goodwill between market and customers.ï‚·Social Factor:These elements mainly focus on social environment and also examine emerging trends. These factors help organisation to understand customers desires. There are few aspects focus on friends, family, neighbour, media and social groups which have impact on someone's attitude, opinion, attitude, regional differences that have impact on sales and profit which is earned by company. In US, mainly people use cab facilities ratherthantheirpersonalvehicles.Soforfulfildemandofcustomerrespective organisation increase productivity of business(Ardley and McIntosh, 2019). In addition, when there is high demand of cab this results in unavailability of service facilities this effects brand image of company.ï‚·TechnologicalFactor:Theseelementsmainlyconsiderrateoftechnological development and innovation which affects industry or market. Factors such as changes in mobile and digital technology, research and development and automation. As US is rapidly grow in advance technology which have advantage to Uber Technologies for running business operation in more effective and efficient manner. There is also negative impact by fast growing technology as easily it leads to obsolescence and also requires highinvestmenttoimplementnewtechnology.Ubertechnologiesuseinnovative 2
Paraphrase This Document
Need a fresh take? Get an instant paraphrase of this document with our AI Paraphraser
technology in their services to build unique brand image of company to achieve high revenues for business operation and also attract customer base.ï‚·Environment Factors:These elements generally involves influence of environment of surrounding and impacts of ecological aspects. This factors involve food, temperature, pollution, sound, natural calamities that influence living beings. In context of Uber Technologies, as it use diesel and petrol cars which create carbon emission and carbon footprints in large quantity. So they pay huge amount of penalties as government make standardaspreventionandcontrolofpollution.Inaddition,governmentgive compensation and subsidy to company which use environment friendly process. ï‚·Legal Factors:This is a responsibility of organisation to understand legal framework whichare allowed in their territories.Factorsincludeconsumerlaw, employment legislation and so on. These factors generally defines rules and standards which are implemented by government thatimpacts on decision of enterprise. In context of respective organisation, there are many rules which are made by government such as documentation, licensing, accessibility of drivers, pollution control and insurance. This results in smooth functioning of enterprise but company have to offer low rate taxi which leads to decrease in cost(Chen and Wang, 2017). From above analysis, it is summarised as Pestle analysis helps company to examine external forces that impact their market and also analyse that how they impact on their business. Uber is facing negative effect by technological, environment and social factors. So this is responsibility of organisation to formulate strategies by proper analyses of external environment to achieve sustainability in business. This leads benefit to enterprise to cover broader market segment and also satisfy customer by offering them high quality of services. Stakeholder Analysis: It is a process which helps in identifying people before the project begins and after this grouping them according to their level of participation, interest and influence them to give their best for attainment of goals and objectives by involvement and communication with them. Importance of stakeholder analysis is to enlist the players which are helpful in attainment of objectives of company, in addition if there is conflict so managers and leaders are responsible for address them in effective manner. 3
TASK2 P2.Examine intrinsic environment and capabilities of Uber Technologies by using appropriate frameworks. The forces and conditions that exist in organisation is termed as internal environment of enterprise. These factors are directly controllable as they are within firm itself. It includes factors like board of director, employee, trade union, resources and so on. For successful operation of business it is important for company to examine internal environment of it. In prospective of Uber Technologies Inc. to analyse micro factors VRIO Analyse in undertaken which is discussed below: VRIO ANALYSIS: This is a tool used to examine internal resources of firm and capabilitieswhicharefindouttosustaincompetitiveadvantage.InregardstoUber Technologies, this model is used to analyse resources of company in order to gain sustainable competitive advantage from industry and also build effectiveness in market segment for make itself different from other competitors. By VRIO analysis resources of company are divided in four distinct categories that plays vital role for strengthen performance of business. RESOURCESVALUABLERAREINIMITABLEORGANISABL E COMPETITIV E ADVANTAGE S Brand imageBrand image---Temporary competitive advantage Service quality Service quality Service quality--Equality competitive advantage InnovationInnovation capability Innovation capability Innovation capability -Sustainable competitive advantage Financial position Financial position Financial position Financial position Financial position Sustainable competitive 4
advantage Valuable Resources:In every organisation, first and foremost resources are valuable. Resources are seen as valuable when allow a firm to implement strategies that improve efficiency and effectiveness of firm utilize opportunities or by reducing threats. It helps in analysing strength of business towards expansions powerful place in market. In context of Uber technologies Inc. , valuable resources includes brand image, service quality, innovation, financial position these are discussed below:ï‚·Brand image:In Uber Technologies Inc(Khedmati and et. al.,2019). pervade huge amount on advertising and promotion of its services to anywhere which can be access and guide customers to use these services. So by this brand image of company is increase in global market through extension of business in various countries. By VRIO analysis of Uber, brand image is precious and valuable resource of enterprise.ï‚·Service Quality:Another important precious or valuable resources of Uber Technologies is service quality. As company provide best quality to customer to satisfy their needs and wants. So by this customer give high rating to company so service quality is become valuable resources in VRIO analysis.ï‚·Innovation:Technologicalinnovationsandadvancementsareusedbyrespective company to match market trends. So it leads to customer satisfaction which highlights valuable resources of business. ï‚·Financial Resources:In context of Uber Technologies Inc(Nagy and et. al., 2018). as there is less competition is in market place. So financial resources can be expand to attract customers. That's why financial resources are valuable to business. Rare Resources:It involves resources which are designed in such way that are rare to acquire by competitors and these resources must be contributed in achievement of business goals effectively. These resources are considered as they play important role in build up business and obtain market position. In perspective of Uber it includes rare resources as employee distribution network, financial resources and so on. Below they are explained:ï‚·Service Quality:By giving better quality Uber Technologies has large amount of trustworthyandloyalcustomers.Ascompanyprovidequickservicestomsatisfy customers so this become rare resources of business. 5
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
ï‚·Innovation:Creativity and innovating aspects of Uber Technologies is high because of huge investment on digital technology in their services which leads to increase in outcome of business. So innovation is considered as rare resources in business. ï‚·Financial positions:As in terms of Uber, for start a new business it requires huge amount or large support of financial needs. As this company gain brand image, so financialpositionisrareresourcesintermsofbusiness(Agapitou,Bersimisand Georgakellos, 2017). Inimitable Resources: It involvesresources which are not copy easily by any business enterprise and increases business. These resources are significant for any organisation for design itself in specific and unique by its resources which are important and gain competitive advantage forcompany.Inimitableresourcesofperspectivecompanyincludesfinancialresources, distribution network and so on. These are describe as under:ï‚·Innovation:In Uber Technologies Inc. use innovative technology in its services for attract more customers which are not easy for competitive rivalries to make their strategies in innovative manner. Thus, it leads to inimitable resources of business. ï‚·Financial Position:As respective company in itself has brand image. It requires huge financialresourcesthat are inimitablefor other competitiveindustry. So financial position is inimitable resources of business. Organisable Resources:In VRIO analysis this is last resource, it explains as resources are not make competitive advantage for business when they are not properly organised. In context of Uber Technologies Inc., it includes organisable resources such financial resources which is discussed below: ï‚·Financial position:In order to increase financial position, Uber Technologies Inc. uses high quality of products in manufacturing and service providing. So by this, cash flow of company is maintained in right manner and revenues of company is increases. Thus, from above analysis, Uber Technologies Inc. , it is analysed as company has different resources like valuable, rare, inimitable and organisable for business operation that consider strength of enterprise. This become helpful in effectiveness of business strategies as by requirement of different situations. 6
TASK 3 P3: Applying Porter's five force model to evaluate competitive forces of Uber: This model cab be define and analyse as the five competitive forces that shapes every industry and helps in determine strengths and weaknesses. This force is frequently used to identify an industry's structure to determined corporate strategy. Porters five force model is used to understand competitive aspect of Uber are defined below(Habib and Hasan, 2019): Porter's five force analysis:It is used to analyse competitive factors of Uber that enables business to chose effective strategies according situations. It is also help to explain why industry is able to sustain different level of productivity. This factors are describe below in the context of Uber technologies. Bargaining power of supplier:It is most important factor of this analysis that has major impact on the organization. This is determined by the power of supplier to increment their price. If there is number of supplier in market than their bargaining power is low opposed. But if there are fewer supplier and more industry needs their help, the stronger their ability to charge industry. In the context of Uber technologies, bargaining power of supplier is high due to requirement of professional drivers. Gas and oil suppliers has major impact on transformation industry and raises in their price create risk for respective company. Thus the bargaining power of supplier is high in the context of Uber technologies, it could impact its position in negative way which could be disadvantage for the industry. Bargaining power of buyers:It is an assessment of how easy it is for buyer of industry to drive prices down. This driven by ,the number of buyers in the industry and importance of each buyer in organisation. It is also important that how it is easy for buyer to switch to one supplier to another. In the terms of Uber bargaining power of buyers is relatively high because of the availability of competitors in the transformation industry such as local taxis, Tesla etc. costumer can easily switch to another supplier due to increment in waiting times, which could be threat for the respected company. Thus the bargaining power of buyers could impact the company, it could also impact the sales and revenue of Uber as well as distribution network. It leads to retain customers of business from switching to others(Leonidou and et. al., 2017). Threat from new entrance:It is also significant factor that has an immense influence over transportation companies.An established company like Uber attracts others competitors to have share of their success. Company has been making profits since its inception, and they has 7
customer loyalty base that are loyal and trustworthy for firm. In the context of uber, the treatof new entrance is low because of high level of investment in this industry. There are many entry barrier in transportation industrywhich make the entrance of competitive industry quite difficult. Thus, this factor has positive impact on respected company, it is not easy for new entrance to compete well know and established company like Uber. Its policies offers using effective software to control the cost of business in order to make effective operation of business. Uber ha no threat from new entrance that has prominent impact on the profitability and in terms of getting competitive advantages form market(Wieland, Hartmann and Vargo, 2017). Rivalry among existing competitors:This is the strength of competition in the industry. The tend of contraction of company appears to be higher than previous year, and the existing companies in the market compete with both supplier and buyer. All the industries are not equal in the terms of competition. Threats from rivalry is strengthen for completion of transport industry. As in transport industry competition from rivalry is increased compared past few years and currently transport industries are competing from both car drivers as well as customers. Due to operations of this company in all over world its competition has been increase. Thus this factor of the model is threat for the respective company because of the high level of competition around the world. But with the innovation and new ideas in their organisation they can give high competition to their rivalry. Threat from substitutes:A substitutes is well known fear that is experiencedin a competitive business environment. In the transportation industry there are numbers of member in organisation that can provide replacement for Uber service. With the service quality that company provides, taxis services is the closet opponent and potential substitute emerging from the traditional transportation industry. There are several companies that are offer similar services from Uber. Thus to deal with this terms company respected company can try to differentiate its services so they can attract new customers such as using eco friendly and customer friendly services. Thus, from the above discussion on five force model of porter, model impact the uber in dynamic way that creates competitive benefits as well as berries for firm. In term making effective stand in potential market of UBER technologies. Company should focus on making effective services and use innovativeness in their business(Olson and et. al.,2018). From the above analysis, it is clear that bargaining power of buyers in case UBER is high due of 8
Paraphrase This Document
Need a fresh take? Get an instant paraphrase of this document with our AI Paraphraser
availability of similar services available in market. In order to deal with this, company requires to focus more on its services in order to differentiate them from the services offered its competitors. Threat of new entry in context of UBER is low due to its loyal customer base and big brand name. Threat of new substitute in context of UBER is also high so there is a need of continuous effort by company in order to provide excellent services to its customers in order to TASK4 P4: Describe theories and strategic business plan. Ansoff's matrix:This model is essential for strategies marketing planning where it can be applied to look at opportunities to grow revenue for business through developing new product and service tapping into new market. It is also use to evaluate opportunities for company to increase their sales through showing alternative combination for new markets. In the terms of Uber following elements of this model(Chen, Eshleman and Soileau, 2017). ï‚·Diversification:It is strategy that is based on the development new product and service, and entrance into new market that leads into expansion of exploring business. This strategy plays significant role in achievement of effective goodwill in industry with large market shares and revenue. It is associated with risk and investment. Adoption of this strategy is risky for UBER as with this company will enter in newmarket with new service. Proper analysis should be done by enterprise before enter into new market in order to achieve set goals and objectives. ï‚·Market development:This is a strategic step taken by company to develop the existing market rather than looking for new market. It is contribute to rising coverage of business and increasing sales and customer base of business. It is less risky, costly and time consumed but not effective in all situations and conditions. UBER can adopt this strategy by enter in new market. With this, company will be able to serve more customers which will increase market share and profitability of organisation. ï‚·Product development:This strategy is related to development of new product and service for existing market. That contribute the boarding of market of industry. It has significant advantages of raising profit and improving business quality. It is also increase consumer base for the business. It is quite expensive and risky approach for this business. 9
In context of UBER, company can introduce new services in market such as company can launch its own app of money transferring or can enter in food market. ï‚·Market penetration:It is suitable when the condition of business is going down due to low promotion of goods and services. This strategy is used when the business seeks to increase sales growth of its existing product or services and promotion activities are raise for existing goods(Peris-Ortiz and Ferreira, 2017). For adoption of thisstrategy, company require to offer various schemes and discounts in order to increase its sales. Strategic management plan:This plan is a document used of communication within the organization. Strategies management planing is the process of documenting and established a direction of business. This plane gives place to record your mission, vision, and value as well as long term gaols and actions plans. In the terms of Uber management plan for adopting product development are discussed below: ï‚·Mission:It define as the core purpose of an organization or company. A summary of the aims and core value. A mission clearly tells what organization do for customers, this comprehensive but also very specific apart from other organization. ï‚·Vision:This statement is the anchor point of any strategies plan it outline what organization want to achieve in the future and gives purpose to the existence of Uber organization(Bentley-Goode, Newton and Thompson, 2017). ï‚·Value:Uber's value are engaged taking care about time limits, efforts and ability of business to serve their customer in effective way. It leads to offer fast affordable public transportation for general public and business customer for who needs to deliver product. ï‚·Finance:In the terms of fulfilling the above mission of business Uber required 60% fund from external sources such as bank loans, public finance and 40% of internal sources reserve capital, selling of assets etc(Prashar, 2018). ï‚·Customers:ForUbertargetscustomerofbusinessareincludesgeneralpeople, individuals, professional as well as business users to fulfil the mission and objectives of business. ï‚·Monitoring: In terms of Uber should focus on directing of estimated plan so as to meet effectiveness in project and implement needed change. This leads to effective and effectual application of plan. 10
ï‚·Resources:FortheabovepurposeresourcesofUberincludeshumanresources, equipments, machinery sources of energy and water resources. Porter's generic strategy:Michel porter provides strategies model guides senior manger in explore business opportunities and helps in minimising threats that create barrier in effective implementation of business strategies. In the context of uber following are the strategies that provide significant competitive merits. ï‚·Differentiation strategies: It considered as relevant tool for increasing brand image and profits for business. In this strategy huge investment required for developing specific goods and services. For increasing customer loyalty towards brand or company and building trust in a mind of buyers towards the quality. This leads to attain higher profits and revenue for business through setting goals and plan(Rogmans and Abaza, 2019). IN context of UBER, company requires to focus more on various aspects in order to ensure effective delivery of its services to its customers. With this, company can get competitive benefit and can sustain in market for long time. ï‚·Cost leadership strategy: this strategy is suitable for companies who needs to become lowest cost procedure within a industry. It based on lowering the cost of product and service so that company can take advantages of it. It is significant approach for getting customer'sattentionandencouragingthemforassessinggoodsandservices.For implementation of this strategy, UBER requires to focus on every aspect through which it can reduce the cost of its services in order to attract large number of customers. ï‚·Focus strategy: Final stage of above method is based on focusing on one of the element from cost leadership and differentiation strategy at a time. Focus on both may fails to solve problems arise in business organisation. Thus, it is analyse that Uber already had loyal customer base that shows effective preference, oration,andcapabilitiestosurecustomeraspertheirrequirement.Companyfacehuge competition form rivalry. Respective firm needs to focus on differentiation strategy for making different brand image(Johansson and Kask, 2017) 11
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
CONCLUSION From the above discussion it can be conclude that, there are different forces that has prominent impact on business performance with the respect to strength to organization. This report contains distinct models and theories for analysing micro and macro environment of business considered for making firm enable to explore growth opportunities and diminishing threats, further, various competitive factor that impacts organization in significant ways are explained in order to find out effectiveness and efficiency of business. Moreover, management plan for business is discussed for effective application of strategies which make firm enable to take successful decision and help in achievement of business goals(Kitsios and Kamariotou, 2019)x.. 12
REFERENCES Books and Journals Nagy, J. and et. al., 2018. The role and impact of Industry 4.0 and the internet of things on the business strategy of the value chain—the case of Hungary.Sustainability.10(10). p.3491. Leonidou, L.C. and et. al.,2017. Internal drivers and performance consequences of small firm green business strategy: The moderating role of external forces.Journal of business ethics.140(3). pp.585-606. Chen,Y.,Eshleman,J.D.andSoileau,J.S.,2017.Businessstrategyandauditor reporting.Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory.36(2). pp.63-86. Bentley-Goode, K.A., Newton, N.J. and Thompson, A.M., 2017. Business strategy, internal control over financial reporting, and audit reporting quality.Auditing (Ostos, Hinderer and Bravo,2017)(Ardley and McIntosh,2019)(Chen and Wang,2017) (Khedmati and et. al.,2019)(Agapitou, Bersimis and Georgakellos,2017)(Habib and Hasan,2019)(Wieland,Hartmann and Vargo,2017)(Olson and et. al.,2018)(Peris- Ortiz and Ferreira, 2017)(Prashar,2018)(Rogmansand Abaza,2019)(Johansson and Kask, 2017)(Kitsios and Kamariotou,2019)(Bentley-Goode, Newton and Thompson, 2017)(Chen, Eshleman and Soileau,2017)(Leonidou and et. al.,2017)(Nagy and et. al., 2018): A Journal of Practice & Theory.36(4). pp.49-69. Kitsios,F.andKamariotou,M.,2019.Businessstrategymodellingbasedonenterprise architecture: a state of the art review.Business Process Management Journal. Johansson, T. and Kask, J., 2017. Configurations of business strategy and marketing channels for e-commerce and traditional retail formats: A Qualitative Comparison Analysis (QCA) in sporting goods retailing.Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services.34. pp.326- 333. Rogmans, T. and Abaza, W., 2019. The impact of international business strategy simulation games on student engagement.Simulation & Gaming.50(3). pp.393-407. Prashar, A., 2018. TQM as business strategy: a meta-analysis review.International Journal of Productivity and Quality Management.23(1). pp.74-89. Peris-Ortiz, M. and Ferreira, J.J., 2017. Cooperation and networks in small business strategy: An Overview. InCooperative and Networking Strategies in Small Business(pp. 1-9). Springer, Cham. Olson, E.M. and et. al.,2018. The application of human resource management policies within themarketingorganization:Theimpactonbusinessandmarketingstrategy implementation.Industrial Marketing Management.69. pp.62-73. Wieland,H.,Hartmann,N.N.andVargo,S.L.,2017.Businessmodelsasservice strategy.Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science.45(6). pp.925-943. Habib,A.andHasan,M.M.,2019.Businessstrategyandlaborinvestment efficiency.International Review of Finance. Agapitou, C., Bersimis, S. and Georgakellos, D., 2017. Appraisal of CRM implementation as business strategy option in timesof recession: The role of perceived value and benefits.InternationalJournalofBusinessScience&AppliedManagement (IJBSAM).12(2). pp.18-31. (Ostos, Hinderer and Bravo,2017)(Ardley and McIntosh,2019)(Chen and Wang,2017) (Khedmati and et. al.,2019)(Agapitou, Bersimis and Georgakellos,2017)(Habib and 13
Hasan,2019)(Wieland,Hartmann and Vargo,2017)(Olson and et. al.,2018)(Peris- Ortiz and Ferreira, 2017)(Prashar,2018)(Rogmansand Abaza,2019)(Johansson and Kask, 2017)(Kitsios and Kamariotou,2019)(Bentley-Goode, Newton and Thompson, 2017)(Chen, Eshleman and Soileau,2017)(Leonidou and et. al.,2017)(Nagy and et. al., 2018) Khedmati, M. and et. al., 2019. Business strategy and the cost of equity capital: An evaluation of pureversushybridbusinessstrategies.JournalofManagementAccounting Research.31(2). pp.111-141. Chen,L.andWang,J.,2017.Businessstrategy,compensationpolicyandinnovation performance:Abehavioralperspective.Compensation&BenefitsReview.49(4). pp.189-205. Ardley, B. and McIntosh, E., 2019. Business strategy and business environment: The impact of virtual communities on value creation.Strategic Change.28(5). pp.325-331. Ostos, J., Hinderer, H. and Bravo, E., 2017. Relationship between the business environment and businessstrategytypes:EvidenceinPeruviancompanies.RevistaUniversidady Empresa.19(32). pp.61-86. (Ostos, Hinderer and Bravo,2017)(Ardley and McIntosh,2019)(Chen and Wang,2017) (Khedmati and et. al.,2019)(Agapitou, Bersimis and Georgakellos,2017)(Habib and Hasan,2019)(Wieland,Hartmann and Vargo,2017)(Olson and et. al.,2018)(Peris- Ortiz and Ferreira, 2017)(Prashar,2018)(Rogmansand Abaza,2019)(Johansson and Kask, 2017)(Kitsios and Kamariotou,2019)(Bentley-Goode, Newton and Thompson, 2017)(Chen, Eshleman and Soileau,2017)(Leonidou and et. al.,2017)(Nagy and et. al., 2018) 14